-=-
Menu
Tournaments
Profile
Poll
Latest videos
Latest comments
2019-03-19: "Nothing has bee..." -Grytolle
2019-03-18: "yo sj, change f..." -ThunDer
2019-03-17: "Considering it ..." -Vegito
2019-03-17: "It was a test ..." -MasterSven
2019-03-17: " and ty for ac..." -Vivando
2019-03-17: "4v4 mappool vot..." -Ragnarok
2019-03-17: "Why does this s..." -Laro24
2019-03-17: "someone had to ..." -Krzysiek
2019-03-17: "Next time pick ..." -Antix
2019-03-17: " v ..." -Ragnarok
2019-03-17: "GG WP ALL! E..." -ThunDer
2019-03-16: "v interesting m..." -Ragnarok
Latest matches
flag CX [09:03] [CDF]flag
flag CX [13:02] [CDF]flag
flag CX [11:00] [GpW]flag
flag CX [08:04] [GpW]flag
flag -t3> [12:07] CXflag
flag CX [09:02] -t3>flag
flag CX [11:08] -t3>flag
flag -t3> [04:03] CXflag
flag [GpW] [04:03] [CDF]flag
flag CX [13:03] -t3>flag
Latest forum posts
By: Vegito, in: A new balance proposalImproving rules 2019-03-19 23:00
I, as you said, didn't try the changes but watchin...
By: Ragnarok, in: A new balance proposalImproving rules 2019-03-19 20:49
If anything I'm in full support of it then. Wo...
By: Treylina, in: A new balance proposalImproving rules 2019-03-19 19:26
[quote="Ragnarok"]-snip-[/quote] The height ner...
By: Ragnarok, in: A new balance proposalImproving rules 2019-03-19 14:47
I'm all for rabbit inclusion, but since I don't ha...
By: Treylina, in: A new balance proposalImproving rules 2019-03-19 03:00
TL;DR: Try out the balance changes with the prov...
More...!

JJnet's forum

«Latest posts» «Latest threads» «Search» «User CP»

View post
Anubis
avatar
Return to thread2018-09-11 15:29
@Toni It was a bit of a last minute vote. I believe 7 people were invited to the council in total, out of which 5 voted. I had played most maps in 2v2 and/or 3v3 except three of them, when I was invited to vote on Sunday, and the voting deadline was until midnight on the same day so I only had the evening after coming back home to play or look through all maps in detail. Other council members had already started testing the maps from the afternoon, though. One more person invited in the voting council seemed too busy to pick 3 maps on time that day, as he had only played two of them and was busy at the time. Giving a few more days notice might have allowed more people to participate in the voting.

I do like the ideas of cooba and Jelly Jam that would let more maps get in, either from this or next season, as it was indeed a difficult choice to pick only 3 maps out of all the quality entries we got. I don't really like the idea of completely replacing the voting council with a public vote, though. By picking a voting council it's easier to make sure only people who would vote based on objective criteria in accordance with the contest requirements are allowed to vote. Otherwise clan members or level making group members would coordinate their votes according to their own group's interests. I don't see how including some of the level creators would be doable either, as they could still vote in a way that would move their map in the ranking, even when not voting for their own map.